Mark 3:1-6; Exodus 20:8-11; Micah 6:6-8
Robert M Watkins
The man with the withered hand is the healthiest person in this story besides Jesus. He knows what is wrong, seeks repair, chooses the best person for the job, and awaits the results. If all of us could be such good patients, our physicians would rejoice with loud shouts of praise and deep songs of joy!
No, the sickest folks in the story are the ones who deemed themselves the healthiest, which is often the way. Not surprisingly, they are the good folks of a congregation. Mark issues a warning to us all–beware the presumed godliness of the godly–too many times, something wholly other is at play.
Why is that?
An alarming trend in the contemporary American church is that the more pronounced the adherence to strict orthodoxy, the more likely it is that there will be a schism in the congregation and that, sadly, with almost certainty, that congregation will split. It seems that more sure we become of what God wants and what faith practice includes, the more likely we are to become judgmental, divisive, and derisive of those who are different from us or question our self-proclaimed orthodoxy. We see it here in our own community. We see it at Presbytery meetings. We see it throughout our denominations. A declaration of being right leads to a dangerous precipice.
But now, it is the Sabbath.
The Fourth Commandment instructs strict observation of the Sabbath–no one in the faith community, including the animals, is to engage in labor of any kind. The day is to be one of quiet, of contemplation, of prayer, of being still and knowing God.
As God gave this dictum to Moses, God did so to make the experience of shalom a regular piece of human existence. On the Seventh Day, the community would fall still and enter the peace of being with God. All other cares and concerns were to fall away and be set aside. For that single day, all would in God, through God, of God, with God, and for God. God did not need or desire that we slavishly follow this rule as an oppressive, overbearing dictum, stifling us and breaking us. It was meant to open us to the eternal presence of God and to become mindful of the eternal wonder of the creation itself, the chosen home of God with his people.
But something went amiss.
The Fall infected keeping the Sabbath. A day of joyful, peaceful rest became something else through human interpretation–an interpretation marred by sin–in this case, the inability to keep the reason for a commandment in focus, replacing it with blind obedience and brute enforcement.
But there is a man with a withered hand in the congregation this one Sabbath. Jesus sees him right away. He sees the suffering brought by the predicament. He notes the loss the man endures in not being able to be a full participant in life. He sees the man’s handicap for what it is–it breaks him, keeps him from being what God intends for full human life as the Image of God. In short, he sees a problem to be fixed.
However, Jesus sees even more than the man’s obvious brokenness. He also perceives the brokenness of the rest of the congregation, too. He sees their plotting, scheming, and judgmentalism. They see Christ, but as a threat to their carefully built, strongly enforced ORDER. They have intricately constructed a paper-box palace of rules and regulations that form their communion. Somewhere along the way, God was dismissed, replaced by ORDER itself. Anyone who does not believe in the rules–rules from God, by the way–is to be severely checked and watched and, eventually, repudiated. ORDER will be kept. Christ feels compassion for their blindness, their obtuseness, and their loss of God. They are every bit as broken as the man with the withered hand.
So, Jesus asks them a question–
Is it lawful on the Sabbath to do good or to do harm,
to save life or to kill?
Of course, no one says a blessed thing–they have already made up their minds–they were made up long before any of them rose for church that morning and long before Jesus’ shadow even darkened their vision.
An old farmer who happened to be an Elder on a Session I moderated repeatedly responded to issues before us with a flat statement of purpose–
It’s my opinion, don’t muddy me with the truth!
What Jesus wants everyone to see–the truth–is that in every encounter with one another, our first question is never to be one about the rulebook, but always and eternally about GOD–What does God require of us? What does God want of us? What does God want to happen in this situation?
The old prophet Micah asked the question for all of us, and he found the answer–
What does the Lord require of you?
To do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly before your God.
That is the blueprint for our congregational life. That is our purpose. That is our end. And that is all we are ever to be about.
It also means that, at times, the rulebook gets tossed aside, even when the rule is one as noble, as pure, and as holy as the Fourth Commandment. On this Sabbath morning, Jesus found a man for whom Sabbath shalom was a wish and dream because he was not whole, well, or able. His need meant action–holy action and sacred work–even on the Sabbath–for compassion would bring more peace, more realization of the holy, and more communion than any other expression of faith in the one holy God.
What does that look like?
It happens when we set our need to be right, our presumption of knowledge too marvelous for words, and our quick moves to judge one another’s fitness for inclusion, and instead see everyone, including ourselves, through the eyes of God, the Waiting Father, the Lord of compassion, mercy, and grace who welcomes us no matter how wretched we are and will see us well, whole, and full, regardless of whether or not loving someone else fits codes, rules, and regulations.
God never leaves the withered as they are.
Amen.